The Unaccustomed Earth – A Review

November 11, 2012

Book Reviews

With the publication of Unaccustomed Earth, Jhumpa Lahiri, the subtle chronicler of immigrant Bengali Diaspora, has arrived at a coveted literary milestone. Dissolution of identity on account of migration is more a backdrop than a force holding the centre stage of her new anthology. Commoner yet grimmer human predicaments like death, deceit and desertion play defining roles in the lives of the characters of The Unaccustomed Earth.  The resultant perspective is rich in tonal contrast, achieved by the emergence of the second generation of immigrants, the children of the first movers.

Most of her earlier stories from The Interpreter of Maladies showcase the psychosocial conflicts of the characters, their isolation, the crises of identity and the struggle to belong. The first generation émigrés were like first settlers to an ‘unaccustomed earth’ braving the rough winds and weather alien to them, survival and sustenance being more the core of their problem.  The epithet receives its due honour as it becomes the title of the succeeding volume.

The Unaccustomed Earth picks up the threads right off the preceding volume. The first wave of settlers has arrived for long; some have switched to the new culture aggressively even as some stick to the old far off land. Then there are some who are straddling across two boats. Food, clothes and customs rendered unpalatable by the Indian ethos pose major stumbling blocks to smooth transition for some. Unable to cope, they fiercely cling to the earlier ways of life, almost as if mourning. The problem takes an acute turn when they succumb to the basic biological urge of perpetuating their existence through their children.

Regardless of their levels of assimilation, the sense of alienation has been passed to their offspring as if genetically. However, the children have become naturalized citizens of the adopted land imbibing its customs and mores. Not only they feel proud of it, they find the Indian culture incongruent. Their complete migration to the American culture as they move into adulthood is checked by their parents, causing friction and shaping their future.

The title story of the collection tells us about Roma, living in Seattle with her husband Adam and their toddler son Akash. She hasn’t joined her work after her mother’s sudden demise and is expecting her second child. Roma’s father is a consummate immigrant, naturalized to the extent that he could be easily mistaken for an American in his old age with his gray hair and fair skin. He conforms to the intense individualism manifest in the American culture. He lives alone and makes his own meal, loves to hop around the world, living off a suitcase.  He has developed interest in Mrs Bagchi, a widower and a naturalized immigrant like him. Their paths had crossed on one of the packaged tours and they have been planning their future tours in tandem since then.  Roma’s father is an epitome of the free spirit who sends over picture post-cards to her periodically. “Occasionally there was a sentence of the weather. But there was a never a sense of her father’s presence in those places.”  

Ruma has not been able to get over her mother’s instincts who had refused to shun her Indian identity. Although she has chosen to marry an American, much to the mortification of her mother, there are unmistakeable streaks of the orient in her.  She feels guilty for not taking due care of his father as an Indian daughter would and is constantly worried about him. She yearns to be with him if only to invoke the old times when her mother was still alive. However, when her father pays her a visit she fears that he may decide to stay with them, not sure how Adam will receive it in the long run and what impact it will have on the family she has so carefully nurtured.

Hell-Heaven is told from the perspective of a young girl whose mother hated the American way of life, enforced Bengali customs at home, forbade her from going on dates or even to Harvard square with a friend, eating turkeys and touching wine. Her mother had a secret crush on Pranab, an acquaintance who married an American girl Deborah.  Her recurrent refrain to the daughter is, “Don’t you think you will get away with marrying an American, the way Pranab Kaku did.”

Choice of Accommodation is about secret personal rivalry between Amit and his American wife, Megan. Their emotions are tested when they travel to Langford to attend the marriage of Pam Borden, with whom Megan suspects Amit of having had an affair. Both Only Goodness and Nobody’s Business have Indian Immigrant girls as protagonists, painfully seeking to balance their lives with their English and Egyptian counterparts, respectively.

The last three stories are in the form of a triptych about Hema and Kaushik, childhood acquaintances and lovers later on. Lahiri has rendered poignant urgency to the tales using alternate perspectives, summing up the conflicts and the fates of the émigrés, the immigrant and the vagabond.   Once in a Lifetime is a tale about Kaushik’s parents returning to America after staying in Bombay for seven years. As they stay together at Hema’s house, her mother and Mrs Chowdhary represent two opposing forces at different ladders of assimilation and at a conflict with each other. Hema’s mother dresses and eats in typically Indian manner, Kaushik’s mother dresses and eats like Americans, smokes cigarettes and loves to have her drinks. For a while the families stay together in a strained dichotomy. The next story, Year’s End, is told from Kaushik’s perspective. His mother is already dead as he receives a call from his father to inform him about his new mother and stepsisters. He tries to stay with the newly defined family, struggling to suppress his emotions poorly. Eventually, he breaks free, driving away aimlessly with his mother’s photographs towards the desolate North Atlantic shores. Going Ashore is mostly told from the author’s perspective. Both Hema and Kaushik have transcended beyond their Indian or American identities and are more of global citizens. Hema is now a professor of Latin. She is visiting Rome, taking advantage of her colleague’s unoccupied apartment. Kaushik has evolved into a war photographer and is reported to have visited violent Latin American destinations and Salvador.  A map of Gaza strip is a permanent fixture on the wall of his apartment in Rome. The two run into each other like fish to water. However, Hema’s marriage with Navin has already been fixed and Navin is scheduled to move to Hong Kong on a new job. Eventually, they break away to their respective ends.

 Jhumpa Lahiri is a master of captivating narratives. Her language flows with purpose and grace without many swirls and ripples. Her style is minimalist and restrained. Sentences are precise and apt but suffused with nuances and a casual reader risks overlooking the undercurrent.  “It was colder than Rome, a cold that emanated from stone, and instead of her leather jacket Hema now wore a peacoat of Kaushik’s, grateful for the weight over her shoulders, remembering that other coat of Kaushik’s she’d so hated wearing when she was a girl, back when they were nothing but already something to each other.”

She doesn’t set much store by floral sentences but her prose is not bereft of imageries and symbolism. Planting flowers in unyielding soils has a deeper meaning in the title story. Sarcophagi appear twice in Going Ashore and aptly hint at the futures in store for Hema and Kaushik.

The progress of stories in the collection marks an evolution in the concepts of home and belongingness. The further we move, the more we find home and identity becoming fluid concepts for the cast. “It didn’t matter where she was in the world, or whether or not she was dying; she had always given everything to make her homes beautiful, always drawn strength from her things, her walls. But Kaushik never fully trusted the places he’d lived, never turned to them for refuge. From childhood, he realized now, he was always happiest to be outside, away from the private detritus of life.” 

Strangely, Lahiri’s stories betray barest of traces of people of Indian descent facing adverse societal attitudes in the adopted countries. The range of her focus is often elitist; her characters gravitate towards whiter partners as if to reinforce their status. I am sure there are groups of less fortunate immigrants with entirely different experiences. That said, the dilemmas and agonies haunting the characters of The Unaccustomed Earth are global rather than limited in appeal. The conflicts and alienation of the chosen diaspora are representative of human suffering regardless of the geography.

The Unaccustomed Earth
Author: Jhumpa Lahiri
Publisher: Random House India
Pages: 333

, ,

About umashankar Pandey

The question then is, am I a writer? It is true I wriggle a pen to colour my notepad, or tap at a keyboard to darken the pixels of my desktop screen. If the strings I weave paint a canvas to my readers, borrowing the hues of their own vision, maybe I am.

View all posts by umashankar Pandey

Subscribe

Subscribe to our RSS feed and social profiles to receive updates.

34 Comments on “The Unaccustomed Earth – A Review”

  1. Purnendu Singh Says:

    Jhumpa Lahiri, her stories are as beautiful as she herself if…. I read this book sometime back and fell in love at first read with her .. I went through the review and you have done full justice to the author :)

  2. debajyoti Says:

    i don’t read books and don’t know anything about these writers. but through your posts i get to learn a little bit about them and their work. another fabulous post!!!

  3. Sridevi Datta Says:

    Jhumpa Lahri..my fav author and as you have rightly pointed she’s deceptively simple with a depth that totally blows you off at times unlike Chitra Banerjee who although equally brilliant sometimes tends to border on melodrama and yes although her books do not contain the “barest of traces of people of Indian descent facing adverse societal attitudes in the adopted countries” …the turmoil and chaos which she portrays is universal … I have read all her books not onece but many times and every time I see a new layer being added to my interpretation…for the first time I am reading a review of a book which I have read on your blog and as usual you did full justice to it …Cheers!!

    • umashankar Says:

      Thank you for approving the review, SD. I am glad that the assessment is backed by your reading of the book. As said, her stories run deep and can be read several times over. Many thanks to you.

  4. Ashok Ghosh Says:

    Your review’s very well written and certainly whets my appetite to check out the book!
    Not sure if I can agree with your line about having white partners as a sign of elitism – interracial couples are not uncommon and merely reflects the cohabitation in professional space (school, college, work etc). Of course, interracial marriage comes with its own baggage, maybe Jhumpa will deal with it in the next set of stories ;o)

    • umashankar Says:

      Thank you for adding your precious view, Ashok. Hailing exactly from the diaspora Jhumpa Lahiri writes about, it has significant meaning. I guess she has already dealt with that ‘baggage’ in some ways I am sure she will write at length about the same. She is a fabulous author.

  5. C. Suresh Says:

    As usual, a very evocative review

  6. Amit Says:

    I read Interpreter of Maladies when I was too young to understand what I was reading. I enjoyed The Nakesake more. I have read good review of this book and it is in my auspicious wishlist.

  7. Akshay Kumar G Says:

    Ahh! Nice to see how quickly you have moved on from that whole episode. Back to some awesome writing and awesome reviews. Kudos to you, Sir. :)

  8. Ghazala Hossain Says:

    This is one book I look forward to read :)

  9. Ghazala Hossain Says:

    The mother daughter connect and the guilt that an Indian daughter feels sounds intriguing.

  10. The Fool Says:

    Interesting. This being a short story collection – maybe I will check it out. I don’t like short stories much as a pure reader. But as a writer I might like to read to sample her language and narrative technique which you have appreciated.

    • umashankar Says:

      TF, they are more of long than short. In fact, the last three stories are linked together, constituting a novella. You may find The Unaccustomed Earth a relaxing read after your journey through Anathem!

  11. poonam Says:

    I have never read Jhumpa Lahiri, and the way you have written about the book, I might just pick a copy on my way back home….
    Happy Diwali my friend!

    • umashankar Says:

      Lahiri is an addictive writer. I am sure you are going to find her stories irresistible. Happy Diwali to you and your loved ones too, my friend!

  12. Dark Knight Says:

    I’ve never read Jhumpa Lahiri’s work, but the subject matter of this book is one that I’m definitely familiar with since I also reside outside of India. The book definitely sounds interesting.
    Happy Diwali!

  13. panchali Says:

    Oh, I have read this book! Her writing is just brilliant and I was effortlessly dragged into each of the stories….Happy Diwali, Umashankar!

  14. dNambiar11 Says:

    I read this one last year and thought this’s her best book yet. It actually found its way into my list of favourites. I love how she paints very many emotions in these stories. These tales kept going around in my mind long after I’d put the book down.
    I know that this is a book I’ll pick up again. :)
    Great review! Again great job on a collection of short stories. :)

    • umashankar Says:

      That is right, Divya. Lahiri is imminently re-readable. She excels in creating little worlds that grip you with certain force. I am waiting for her next installment! Thank you so much.

  15. Jas Says:

    I haven’t read Lahiri… May be I made up my mind early on that I won’t be able to understand her style.. but it seems I need to give it another thought.

    On a different note, hope you had a wonderful Diwali.

  16. JayadevM Says:

    My friend,

    Wow! Great intro to the works of JL – haven’t read her books. Have to do it now.

    The stories, the characters and the style have been analysed so evocatively. Loved those alliterative elements you brought into play in this post. You are a clever wordsmith.

    Great to read such prose …. I mean the kind you write!

  17. Avada Kedavra Says:

    Nice review. I have been wanting to read this book from a long time.

%d bloggers like this: